Skip to Content

Do I Need a Filling? What Happens When You Have Decay

4 min readLast updated

Perhaps a dentist has told you that you have decay. Perhaps you've spotted a dark mark on a tooth, or something keeps catching your tongue. Either way, the first question is usually the same. Do I need a filling?

Not always. Here's how I decide.

Illustration of a cavity in a back tooth

Not every dark mark is decay

Staining in the grooves of back teeth is common and often harmless. Some dark patches are old decay that stopped long ago and hardened over. So I look closely, and take x-rays where needed, before deciding anything.

WatchSugar and your teeth: why how often mattersDr Daniel Sutcliffe

When decay can be watched rather than drilled

Decay starts in the enamel, the hard outer layer of the tooth. At that early stage it can often be stopped, and sometimes partly repaired, without any drilling at all. That means cleaning the area well, cutting down how often you have sugar, and using a remineralising toothpaste. Then we look at it again at your next visit to check it has stayed still.

Fluoride toothpaste is the standard recommendation in the UK. If you'd rather avoid fluoride, I generally suggest a hydroxyapatite toothpaste, made from the same mineral as your enamel. A 2025 review found hydroxyapatite toothpastes performed comparably to fluoride ones at stopping early decay progressing. It included only four trials, all in young people, so the evidence is promising rather than settled.

When a filling is the right answer

Once decay has broken through into the softer layer underneath, the dentine, or has made a hole, it won't heal on its own. Left alone it usually keeps going, towards the nerve. That's when a filling is the kinder choice.

How I treat it

  • Only the decay comes out. I remove the decayed, softened tooth and keep as much healthy tooth as I safely can. Because white fillings bond to the tooth, I don't need to cut extra away to hold them in.
  • Ozone, if you'd like it. I can apply ozone to the cleaned cavity before it's filled, for £50 per tooth. It's an optional extra and the evidence is still emerging. There's more on my ozone page.
  • A BPA-free filling. I fill the tooth with VOCO Admira Fusion, the only white filling material I use. It contains no BPA and none of the classic resin monomers. My page on BPA-free white fillings explains more.
  • Something stronger if needed. If the cavity is too big for a filling to hold the tooth together, I'll talk to you about a ceramic inlay or onlay.

If the decay is under an old amalgam filling, the amalgam is removed under the full SMART protocol first.

How much does it cost?

A white filling is £199 small, £299 medium or £329 large, the same whether or not an old amalgam is being removed. Your first appointment, the Signature 18-Point Biological & Wellness Discovery, is £169.

Frequently asked questions

Can decay go away on its own?

Early decay in the enamel can often be stopped and may partly repair. Once it has reached the dentine or made a hole, it can't heal by itself.

Does having a filling hurt?

The tooth is numbed first, so most people feel only pressure and vibration.

How long does it take?

Most fillings are done in a single visit.

Can my old amalgam fillings be changed at the same time?

Yes, if you'd like. It's always your choice, and the amalgam is removed under the SMART protocol.

To book, call 020 7099 6651 or message us on WhatsApp.

Written by Dr Daniel Sutcliffe BDS (Manchester, 2004), Fellow of the International Academy of Oral Medicine and Toxicology. Reviewed November 2026.

Source: Chatzidimitriou K et al. The role of hydroxyapatite-based, fluoride-free toothpastes on the prevention and the remineralization of initial caries lesions: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Dentistry, 2025. doi.org/10.1016/j.jdent.2025.105691

Contact Us

At The Bespoke Dentist, we pride ourselves on providing personalised dental care tailored to your needs. Please fill out the contact form below to get in touch. Whether you have a question or want to book an appointment, we're here to help.

Message us on WhatsApp








    Message us on WhatsApp